The
“immigration problem” has been part of America for many years, which represents
the flawless situations we have seen through the news and media. In “Places and
Peoples: The New American Mosaic” by Charles Hirchman and Douglas S. Massey, we
see the American and immigrants perspective of what is considered from the
American mosaic. Known as the “immigration problem” this is what America has
come to categorize the many situations immigrants and their families have to
struggle through once they arrive to this country. This is commonly seen through the news and media as a huge issue to the country. Since the 1970’s and 1990’s
there has been a growth of 5 million immigrants coming to America from Latin
America and Asia. Yet, these newcomers really began since 1965 once the act
allowed skilled professionals like doctors and nurses to migrate to this
country. Later on these individuals will allow entry to their families and this
is how these migrates escalated to more reasons to come to the United States.
The opportunity for a job
and having an act to allow them to obtain this dream made it possible for
undocumented migration to work. There was an act such as the Bracero Program
who allowed Mexicans to have temporary farm work. This situation didn’t stop
there but nearly began because by the year 2000 over 30 million foreign-born
and another 60 million immigrants with their kids had built their life in the
United States. Obtaining a working place and even through immigrant labor is
what drew these immigrants attention and the reason to expand their lifestyle
for a better future. The huge numbers of people show that this labor didn’t
stop them from coming to the United States but encouraged them to take the
opportunity. Their life back home was no improvement and they were willing to take any chance they possibly can to build for themselves and their family. Yet, these immigrants never knew that they will be part of the
influence in the composition of America’s future.
The immigrants
experience to arriving in the United States was the “push and pull” through the
information given to them by immigrants who have already migrated to the United
States. They were filled with information about opportunities and that’s where
these brave and resourceful people decided to migrate to this location. The “push”
action was simple because they were driven to be part of that opportunity
because of an economic development they dreamed of for a better future. These
immigrants didn’t realize the “pull” they would be experiencing through the
risks by simply coming to the United States. The risks for migration are
endless with criminal prosecution, imprisonment or even death when they attempt
to cross the border. These risks are only the beginning to this “pull” because
not being accepted by Americans is really the factor to this controversial
situation of migration to the United States.
Most people and local
news concentrate on how the border is “broken” but less people concentrate on
the day-to-day lives of these immigrants not being accepted by Americans. Yet, what is commonly heard through the news, media and even government officials is how to keep immigrants away and how to make a more secure border. Most
of them reject the idea of giving these immigrants an opportunity, social
justice, and even an identity. This is not very welcoming through a
discrimination response towards the majority of immigrants, mostly towards
African American, American Indians, Mexican Americans, and other minorities.
Yet, the most are Hispanics who don’t seem to fit into the American mosaic because
they can’t be easily categorized or identified through their color. Being
classified as “brown-skinned” makes it difficult to be identified as neither
white nor black, which has been categorized through this manner for years.
Being white or black was easily recognized because being a black person was
still difficult to consider in the United States. Therefore, Hispanics suffer
this race discrimination, inequality, and injustice because they don’t seem to
be neither white nor black but just “brown-skinned”.
David Griffith’s
message and perspective towards this situation is to view these immigrants more
positive because they did contribute to building the American industry, both
economically and socially. He believes that their presence has managed to keep
many jobs such as schools and churches who continue to show active effort in
their area. Not only do we see active effort but their language is also a way
to provide better services and are now required in some work fields. These
immigrants show that their willing to fill up jobs that are at the bottom of
the occupational ladder, who help build the United States to be who we are today.
Yet, they are not being easily recognized or accepted by Americans because of
their identity. After all, who is it that we see working in the near back of
the restaurant we are dining in? How do we know where and who picked the fruit
that we pick up daily from our grocery store? Therefore, why can’t this nation
recognize and support these immigrants who helped build our country and who are
willing to take these bottom occupational jobs? And finally, why can’t we stop
looking at ways to improve the border security instead of improving the
acceptance of these immigrants?
This was a really great post, and I would have to say that I agree with your point of view of this immigration "problem." I was actually having a conversation with a friend about "illegal people," and our conversation took a quick turn for the worst once he voiced his negative view towards immigrants. It is sad, but many people have views similar to those of my friend, views which dictate whether or not we vote for politicians who are more interested in securing the border than giving immigrants a chance at that good, old "American Dream." When looking at it from a different perspective, others may believe that there is simply not enough room in the country to allow everyone in. Another reason for the disdain towards illegal immigrants may stem from the issue of jobs. People know that they can get away with paying immigrants a lower wage, therefore depriving Americans of certain opportunities. However, I believe that both of these claims can be disputed, especially that of immigrants "taking" jobs from Americans. As you stated, @RosieFlower, immigrants perform the behind the scenes jobs, jobs that most Americans would refuse to take part in. Not only are these immigrants paid minimum wage, and oftentimes below minimum wage, its unbelievable to imagine that Americans believe its acceptable to scapegoat immigrants for taking our jobs. That is just a crass ideology, a concept which should not be the popular mindset of our country.
ReplyDeleteTo answer your question, be cannot stop looking at ways to improve border security because of the ignorance, lack of education, and misleading stereotypes that have been socially constructed by Americans and our ancestors. Our negative stereotypes create a type of fear towards outsiders, thus strengthening the support of more serious border security.
Great ideas and reasons lysspo! I completely agree that society needs to improve socially before taking actions for the country. The ignorance of some individuals starts to change within themselves and their beliefs before even considering the values and concept of rights for the country. If this improves perhaps we will be living in a better society.
ReplyDelete